Comparison of racemization rates between vital and endodontically treated teeth for age estimation

Abstract

Amino acid racemization of dentin (AAR) is among the most precise methods for age estimation in unidentified adult cadavers. Although vital teeth are generally used for this technique, cases often have endodontically treated (Endo) teeth only. Therefore, the aim of this preliminary pilot study was to determine the applicability of Endo teeth by comparing AAR rates between vital and Endo teeth. Thirty-six dentin samples from vital teeth and 18 dentin samples from Endo teeth were analyzed, including the maxillary first premolar, maxillary second molar, and mandibular second premolar. Standard calibration curves for the mandibular second premolar and maxillary second molar were compared among vital teeth, Endo teeth, and mixed vital/Endo teeth. Discrepancies between estimated and actual ages were assessed by analyzing the AAR rates for the maxillary first premolar between vital and Endo teeth. The AAR rates for Endo teeth were higher than those for vital teeth in both the mandibular second premolar and maxillary second molar, and the correlation of the standard calibration curve for vital teeth only was highest (r = 0.982836; r = 0.92011467), followed by mixed (r = 0.949579; r = 0.76158) and Endo teeth only (r = 0.896082; r = 0.744991). In the maxillary first premolar, discrepancies were more than 10 years for all 5 Endo teeth, based on the standard calibration curve of vital teeth. The present study suggests that the AAR rates for Endo teeth might be affected by variation in dentin structure between vital and Endo teeth.