Comparison of pool boiling CHF of a polished copper block and carbon steel block on a declined slope

Abstract

ABSTRACT This study conducts a critical heat flux (CHF) experiment on a carbon steel block, and the block is positioned on slope that is declined at angles of 5° and 10°. The results of the carbon steel block experiment were then analyzed and compared with the results obtained from a copper block experiment that had been conducted previously at the same test facility. The comparison showed that several different types of phenomena had occurred, and the carbon steel block CHF at both 5° and 10° was much lower than that of the copper block. Detailed images of the heating surface of each material were acquired by a high-speed camera under different heat fluxes and analyzed. The carbon steel block surface generates more bubbles compared to the copper block under the same heat flux, which indicates that the carbon steel block should have a large number of nucleation sites. This causes a higher CHF. Finally, several existing theories on CHF mechanisms were also analyzed in an attempt to explain the difference of copper and carbon steel. It seemed that the contact angle alone was not sufficient to explain the large CHF decrease in the carbon steel block.