Comparison of physical characteristics between created and natural estuarine marshes in Galveston Bay, Texas

Abstract

Five natural and ten created Spartinaalternifloramarshes in the Lower Galveston BaySystem were compared to determine if there weresignificantly different physical characteristicsassociated with each type of marsh. The saltmarsheswere compared on the basis of microhabitats,length-width ratio, area-perimeter ratio, marsh-wateredge ratio, total size of S. alternifloraplantcommunities, fetch distances, angle of exposure,orientation, and elevation. All physicalmeasurements, except for elevation, were obtained fromphotography analyzed with the use of a GeographicInformation System with digital image processingcapabilities. Differences existed between natural andcreated marshes. The natural marsh sites in this studywere characterized by highly undulant marsh-wateredges, island-like S. alternifloraplant stands,concave shorelines, and low elevations. Createdmarshes were characterized by relatively smoothmarsh-water edges, an unbroken shoreline morphology,convex to straight shoreline configurations, andelevations on the edge and inner portions of the marshhigher than those of natural marshes. The lowelevations of the natural marsh appear to be due tocoastal subsidence in the Galveston Bay area alongwith rising sea level. Reticulated marshes andundulant shorelines appear to be caused by consequentdrowning of the natural marshes. High elevations insome of the created marshes are related to erosion ofthe low elevation marsh or deposition of coarsesediments at the marsh-water edge.