Abstract
ABSTRACT Introduction/Purpose Physical activity in young children is influenced by the childcare physical activity environment. Identifying differences between home-based programs and licensed centers can inform future interventions to facilitate physical activity and its benefits for all children. Our purpose was to compare the physical activity environment in home-based (n = 70) and licensed (n = 54) childcares. Methods Teachers/directors completed an electronic survey regarding respondent/program characteristics, the outdoor/indoor environment, and barriers to promoting physical activity. T-tests and Fisher’s exact tests compared outcomes by program type. Results Home-based programs had more overall (+1.5), active (+0.5), and attractive (+0.6) natural elements, and more portable or fixed (+1.9), creative fixed (+0.9), and screen time (+0.7) equipment compared with licensed centers, which were rated higher quality (+8.9 out of 50 points). Home-based programs provided more indoor time for physical activity (+2.1 min·h−1) and naptime (+3.1 min·h−1), similar outdoor and television time, longer bouts of indoor teacher-led activity (+6.1 min), and higher levels of activity while indoors (+0.5 on a scale from 1 to 7) compared with licensed centers. The most commonly reported barrier to promoting activity was cost of equipment (82.9%–87.8% of programs). Conclusions Despite being rated as lower quality by the state, home-based programs have many physical-activity-promoting attributes. Although some of our findings are in contrast to the extant literature, this may be due to the strong policies regarding home-based childcare programs in place in Michigan. Future research may aim to compare with other states and understand how these environmental differences impact physical activity participation.
Talk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have