Comparison of phenotypical and molecular methods for the identification of bacterial strains isolated from a deep subsurface environment

Abstract

Seventy-four bacterial strains were freshly isolated from a mine gallery. Using these bacteria, we have investigated how a molecular identification based on the analysis of small subunit rDNA sequences would compare in terms of precision and reliability to a more classical comparison of phenotypical descriptions (100 morphological and physiological traits). Our data clearly showed that a phylogenetic analysis of small subunit rDNA sequences is more efficient than classical phenotypic methods for the identification of bacterial strains freshly isolated from a natural environment, because occurrences of misidentification are very much decreased by this method. The lack of rDNA sequences for many described species is probably the major cause of a few failures in molecular identification, as the completeness of the database of small subunit rDNA sequences holds much importance in the degree of uncertainty in such identifications.