Comparison of NTA and Elemental Sulfur as Potential Soil Amendments in Phytoremediation

Abstract

The effect of NTA (nitrilotriacetic acid) and elemental sulfur (S), two soil amendments suggested for the enhancement of metal phytoavailability in phytoextraction, on heavy metal uptake by Nicotiana tabacum (tobacco) and Zea mays (maize) were studied and compared in two Zn-, Cu-, Cd -, and Pb-contaminated soils from northern Switzerland. Experiments were performed in the greenhouse with topsoil (0 to 20 cm) material from two locations, Dornach and Rafz. The Dornach soil was calcareous and had been contaminated by dust emissions from a nearby brass metal smelter. The Rafz soil, free of carbonates, had been polluted by former sewage sludge application.Soil amendments with S increased the solubility (NaNO3 extraction) of Zn and Cd about 10-fold in Dornach soil and up to 30-fold in Rafz soil after 55 days. Zn and Cd removal by N. tabacum and Z. mays, however, increased only about 5.5- and 2.5-fold in these treatments in Rafz soil, respectively, while in the Dornach soil only a slight increase for Cd was found. Repeated NTA application increased soluble Zn, Cu, and Cd about 100-, 20-, and 19-fold in the Dornach soil and 13-, 4-, and 2-fold in the Rafz soil shortly after application. Soluble Pb was increased by NTA up to 50-fold in Rafz soil. After 90 days soluble heavy metal concentrations were only slightly elevated in both soils. Again, however, Zn, Cd, and Cu removal by N. tabacum and Z. mays increased only about 1.5- to 2.5-fold in the two soils, whereas Pb removal by N. tabacum increased about fivefold in the Rafz soil as a result of NTA application