Comparison of NETSIM, NETFLO I, and NETFLO II Traffic Simulation Models for Fixed-Time Signal Control

Abstract

This paper documents a comparative analysis of the NETSIM, NETFLO I, and NETFLO II traffic simulation models when simulating traffic networks with fixed-time signal control. The objective was to find out whether the results of simulating the same traffic network with the three models were compatible. The three models employ different approaches to simulate traffic flow on urban street networks. Four different scenarios with varying network configurations and intersection geometries were simulated for three volume levels. The average speed and delay measures of effectiveness generated by the three models were compared for each scenario. Analysis of variance techniques were used for statistical analyses of the simulation output data. The execution speeds of the models were also compared. The quickness of simulation will be very important in the ITS applications, real-time traffic adaptive systems, and so forth. The results of this study indicated that the estimated measures of effectiveness from the three m...