Comparison of methods for spatial interpolation of fire weather in Alberta, Canada

Abstract

Spatial interpolation of fire weather variables from station data allow fire danger indices to be mapped continuously across the landscape. This information is crucial to fire management agencies, particularly in areas where weather data are sparse. We compare the performance of several standard interpolation methods (inverse distance weighting, spline, and geostatistical interpolation methods) for estimating output from the Canadian Fire Weather Index (FWI) system at unmonitored locations. We find that geostatistical methods (kriging) generally outperform the other methods, particularly when elevation is used as a covariate. We also find that interpolation of the input meteorological variables and the previous day’s moisture codes to unmonitored locations followed by calculation of the FWI output variables is preferable to first calculating the FWI output variables and then interpolating, in contrast to previous studies. Alternatively, when the previous day’s moisture codes are estimated from interpolated weather, rather than directly interpolated, errors can accumulate and become large. This effect is particularly evident for the duff moisture code and drought moisture code due to their significant autocorrelation.