Comparison of Long-Wave Infrared Imaging and Visible/Near-Infrared Imaging of Vegetation for Detecting Leaking ${\rm CO}_2$ Gas

Abstract

Recent research demonstrated that ${\mmb CO}_{\mmb 2}$ gas leaking from underground can be identified by observing increased stress in overlying vegetation using spectral imaging. This has been accomplished with both visible/near-infrared (Vis/NIR) sunlight reflection and long-wave infrared (LWIR) thermal emission. During a 4-week period in summer 2011, a controlled ${\mmb CO}_{\mmb 2}$ release experiment was conducted in Bozeman, Montana, as part of a study of methods for monitoring carbon sequestration facilities. As part of this experiment, reflective and emissive imagers were deployed together to enable a comparison of these two types of imaging systems for vegetation-based ${\mmb CO}_{\mmb 2}$ leak detection. A linear regression was performed using time as the response variable with red and NIR reflectances, Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI), and LWIR brightness temperature as predictors. The regression study showed that the reflectance and LWIR brightness temperature data together explained the most variability in the data (96%), equal to the performance of the Vis/NIR reflectance data alone, followed by NDVI alone (90%), and LWIR data alone (44%). Therefore, the two types of imagers contributed in a synergistic fashion, while either method alone was capable of gas detection with increased statistical variability.