Comparison of long-term survivals following hepatectomy for hepatocellular carcinoma according to the time-point of recurrence and treatment modalities for recurrent disease

Abstract

Abstract Objective Disease recurrence following curatively intended hepatectomy for hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) limits oncologic outcome. Based on the extent, location and time-point of tumor recurrence, different therapeutic modalities are available to treat recurrent HCC. Therefore, our aim was to investigate the role of these treatments and the time-point of recurrence on long-term survival. Methods Clinicopathological data of patients, who underwent hepatectomy for HCC at a major hepatobiliary center in Switzerland between 2012 and 2019, were assessed. Patients suffering tumor recurrence were stratified according to the treatment modalities for recurrent HCC including surgical treatment (repeat hepatectomy or liver transplantation), interventional treatment, and conservative treatment (chemotherapy or best supportive care). Groups were compared regarding to overall survival (OS). Additionally, long-term outcomes were compared between patients with early (≤ 12 months) and late (> 12 months) tumor recurrence. Results During the study period, 159 patients underwent hepatectomy for HCC. Median follow-up time was 53 months. After a median time of seven (1-64) months, 74 patients were diagnosed with tumor recurrence (47 %). The majority of patients developed early recurrence (n = 49) and 58 patients had intrahepatic recurrence only. Treatment options were re-resection, liver transplantation, interventional methods, and palliative therapy in 5, 15, 23, and 31 patients, respectively. Surgical treatment was significantly associated with improved OS compared to interventional and conservative treatment (5-year OS: 84% vs. 39% vs. 30%, p < 0.0001). OS was significantly better among patients with late recurrence compared to patients with early recurrence, irrespective of the treatment modality used for the recurrent disease (5-year OS: 70% vs. 38%, p = 0.008). Conclusion Repeat hepatectomy or liver transplantation for recurrent HCC following hepatectomy is associated with better long-term survival compared to interventional or conservative therapies, especially for patients with late tumor recurrence. Patients with intrahepatic HCC recurrence should be evaluated according to the extent of tumor burden, liver function, and functional status to identify the best candidates for a surgical treatment.