Comparison of haploid Tuberosum- Solanum chacoense versus Solanum phureja -haploid Tuberosum hybrids as staminate parents of 4x–2x progenies evaluated under distinct crop management systems

Abstract

The relative value of haploid Tuberosum-Solanum chacoense (TCH) vs. Solanum phureja-haploid Tuberosum (PTH) hybrids as male parents in 4x–2x crosses was estimated under two distinct crop management systems. The first experiment (E#1) was carried out with supplementary irrigation (three times a week) at Hancock-Wisconsin (WI) with 27 families derived from a sub-set of crosses involving 11 tetraploid (4x) cultivars and 10 diploid (2x) clones (3 TCH; 6 PTH; and one TCH-PTH hybrid clone). A second experiment (E#2) was conducted at Rhinelander-WI with the same group of families but it was only rainfed with no supplementary irrigation being provided during the entire course of the assay. For comparison, a complete set of 4x and 2x clones (used as parents) was also planted in each location. Three traits were evaluated in both locations: total tuber yield (TTY), haulm maturity (HM), and plant vigor (PV). Altogether, 18 out of 27 and 10 out of 27 families outyielded the corresponding 4x parents at E#1 and E#2, respectively. Significant differences among all 4x–2x families and among families of the TCH group were observed for TTY at both locations. No difference was found for TTY among families of PTH and [TCH–PTH] groups at each location. A total of 75% and 50% of the TCH families outyielded their 4x parents at E#1 and E#2, respectively. The percentage of families from the PTH group that outyielded their 4x parents at E#1 and E#2 was 83.3% and 25%, respectively. The TCH group had on average lower HM scores than PTH (at both locations) indicating some segregation for earliness. However, the HM values of the 4x–2x families were, in general, higher than those observed for the 4x parents. For PV, the PTH group mean was significantly higher than TCH group only in E#1. The PV values of the 4x–2x families were higher than the 4x-parent group at both locations. Our results indicated that TCH hybrids might be as good parents as PTH to increase the TTY of 4x–2x progenies. In addition, the TCH families displayed a slight higher level of performance under more stressful growing conditions than PTH hybrids as indicated by the assay at Rhinelander. Therefore, selection of genetic materials with potential broad range of adaptation seems to be feasible with both hybrids via the 4x–2x breeding scheme.