Comparison of Efficacy of Topical Carica papaya Leaf Extract and Hemocoagulase in Postoperative Wound Healing After Therapeutic Orthodontic Premolar Extractions: a Split Mouth Study.

Abstract

Introduction Postoperative wound healing is the most important factor in the outcome of any surgical procedure. Wound healing is a dynamic process involving inflammation, neovascularization, granulation, fibroblast proliferation, re-epithelization, and remodeling. It repairs tissue integrity, restoring the body's natural defense barrier. A hastened wound healing will help in the quicker re-establishment of the body's homeostasis. Carica papaya includes vital nutrients and bioactive substances such as minerals, vitamins, and antioxidants. Its primary active ingredientpapaincauses the enzymatic debridement of wounds. Hemocoagulase is a thrombin-like serine protease that is mostly employed for its procoagulant and wound-healing characteristics. It is derived from the venom of Bothrops species of snakes. This study aims to compare the wound-healing properties of topical Carica papaya leaf extract and Hemocoagulase after dental extractions. Materials & Methods For 48 patients requiring bilateral therapeutic dental extraction for orthodontic intervention, Carica papaya leaf extract (Caripill 275mg/5ml) was topically applied to the extraction socket on one side, and Hemocoagulase 0.2 CU solution (Botroclot) was applied to the extraction socket on the other side. The bilateral premolars were extracted for orthodontic treatment under local anesthesia. Patients were asked to apply the solution topically twice daily for seven days and were called forreview on the seventh day. The assessment of the efficacy of both solutions in post-operative wound healing was the objective of the study. Healing was assessed by using a blinded single observer for all patients using Landry's healing index. Results A total of 48 subjects with 96 sites completed the study, with a mean age of 15.4 years. The study population consisted of 24 males and 24 females, which were evenly distributed among the two study groups. On comparison of wound healing index (WHI) scores between the two groups using the Wilcoxon signed rank test, Group A had a significantly higher mean rank than Group B with regards to the wound healing indexscore, and the results were statistically significant (p = 0.037). Conclusion It can be concluded from the study that Carica papaya leaf extract showed better wound healing in post-extraction sockets compared to Hemocoagulase. This study presents the promising useof natural extracts such as Carica papaya in wound healing because they are easily accessible to patients, more economical, and haveno adverse reactions. More studies that focus on natural extracts to promote wound healing are required in the future.