Comparison of different microscopy approaches to quantification of inhibitory effect on thrombus formation under flow conditions by the example of adenosine receptor agonist HE-NECA

Abstract

IntroductionThrombus formation in vitro in flow conditions and its visualization and quantification with the use of microscopy are widely utilized to evaluate activity of compounds with a potential antithrombotic activity. Visualization and quantification of thrombi can be performed with the use of wide-field or confocal microscopy. Acquiring reliable numerical data from wide-field microscopy images of objects which have a complex three-dimensional structure is strongly influenced by the methods used for image analysis. This can be a possible source of inaccuracy in assessment of antithrombotic activity of a tested substance. We aimed to verify how different approaches to the quantification of wide-field images can affect the evaluation of an antiplatelet effect of a tested substance. MethodsWe compared three algorithms of image analysis to evaluate an effect of 2-hexynyl-5′-ethylcarboxamidoadenosine (HE-NECA), a compound of a moderate antiplatelet activity on thrombus formation, and of abciximab - a potent antiplatelet compound. Also, we studied how the results obtained in a wide-field imaging correspond to those obtained by means of confocal imaging. ResultsThree algorithms for analysis of wide-field images showed antiplatelet effect of HE-NECA or abciximab. Absolute values of thrombus area and outcomes of the evaluation of inhibition efficacy of HE-NECA were significantly different between the algorithms. Analysis of volumes and heights of thrombi obtained by confocal imaging confirmed inhibitory effect of HE-NECA, but the evaluated levels of inhibition were significantly different from that obtained by wide-field imaging. DiscussionWe conclude that wide-field imaging provides reliable qualitative data on an inhibitory effect on thrombus formation, despite differences which can emerge from various approaches to image analysis. However, quantitative evaluation and comparison of the efficacy of inhibitors on the basis of total area occupied by thrombi obtained by wide-field microscopy should be made with caution. To obtain a reliable quantitative assessment of the effect of a tested compound on thrombus structure the use of confocal microscopy is inevitable.