Comparison of CYGNSS and Jason-3 Wind Speed Measurements via Gaussian Processes

Abstract

Wind is a critical component of the Earth system and has unmistakable impacts on everyday life. The CYGNSS satellite mission improves observational coverage of ocean winds via a fleet of eight micro-satellites that use reflected GNSS signals to infer surface wind speed. We present analyses characterizing variability in wind speed measurements among the eight CYGNSS satellites and between antennas, using a Gaussian process model that leverages comparisons between CYGNSS and Jason-3 during a one-year period from September 2019 to September 2020. The CYGNSS sensors exhibit a range of biases, mostly between −1.0 m/s and +0.2 m/s with respect to Jason-3, indicating that some CYGNSS sensors are biased with respect to one another and with respect to Jason-3. The biases between the starboard and port antennas within a CYGNSS satellite are smaller. Our results are consistent with, yet sharper than, a more traditional paired comparison analysis. We also explore the possibility that the bias depends on wind speed, finding some evidence that CYGNSS satellites have positive biases with respect to Jason-3 at low wind speeds. However, we argue that there are subtle issues associated with estimating wind speed-dependent biases, so additional careful statistical modeling and analysis is warranted.