Comparison of bupivacaine and levobupivacaine in continuous axillary brachial plexus block

Abstract

Aims: This study compares bupivacaine – lidocaine and levobupivacaine – lidocaine administrations in terms of initiation and duration of motor and sensorial blockage, total number of additional analgesic applications, analgesic amount consumed in 24 hours, side-effects and hemodynamic effects in continuous axillary brachial pleksus block in hand and forearm surgery. Methods: Thirty ASA I & II physical status patients, scheduled hand or forearm surgery were enrolled for of the two groups in a randomized study. Axillary catheter duly placed in both group with appropriate guided techniques. Patients in group B received 0. 5% bupivacaine 20 ml + 2% lidocaine 20 ml and group L received 0. 5% levobupivacaine 20 ml + 2% lidocaine 20 ml through the axillary catheter. Initiation and duration of motor and sensorial block, total number of additional analgesic applications and analgesic amount consumed in postoperative 24 hours were recorded. Pre-block, peri-operative and post-operative blood pressures and heart beat rates were also recorded. Block application duration, operation duration, tourniquet duration and demographic data of patients (age, sex, weight, and length) were recorded. Demanded and applied analgesic doses by the patient controlled analgesia devices, side effects and complications were also recorded. Results: There was no statistically significant difference between two groups in terms of initiation and duration of motor and sensorial block, amount of analgesic consumed in 24 hours, demanded and applied analgesic doses by the patient controlled analgesia devices and hemodynamic data (p>0. 05). There is a mild and positive relation between block application duration and patient weight. (p=0. 014; r=0. 444) Conclusion: Both bupivacaine+lidocaine and levobupivacaine+lidocaine combinations can safely be used in axillary continuous brachial plexus block without any difference in terms of initiation and duration of block, total analgesic amount consumed. Their duration of action and effect on hemodynamic responses are similar.