Comparison of Bone Formation After Sinus Membrane Lifting Without Graft or Using Bone Substitute “Histologic and Radiographic Evaluation”

Abstract

Sinus floor elevation without using autogenous bone graft or bone substitute will eliminate donor site morbidity and reduce the cost and the risk of infection. We evaluated the bone gain after sinus membrane elevation without graft or using bone substitute in the same maxilla. Dental implants were inserted simultaneously as a 1-stage procedure. In a split-mouth design, we conducted a randomized double-blinded clinical trial performing sinus lifts and simultaneous implant insertion in 10 healthy patients (n=20). On the 1 site, we performed graft-less sinus lift (group 1) and on the other site Cerabone was used as bone substitute (group 2), respectively. The quantity and quality of bone gained in each sinus were evaluated and compared radiologically and histomorphometrically. After 6months, the average gain of bone height was 6.21 and 9.58mm in group 1 and 2, respectively, as measured radiologically (P<.001, P<.001). Histomorphometric examination showed significantly higher thickness of trabeculae and bone formation in group 1 (P=.003 and P=.002). However, the neovascularization was higher, but not significantly (P=.288). Radiological bone gain was similar in both groups. However, histomorphometric examination showed superior bone formation in graft-less group as compared to the Cerabone group. The blood clot seems to be an adequate filler and excellent medium for bone formation. More studies in split-mouth design are needed to compare different bone substitutes.