Comparison of a highly porous titanium cup (Tritanium) and a conventional hydroxyapatite-coated porous titanium cup: A retrospective analysis of clinical and radiological outcomes in hip arthroplasty among Japanese patients

Abstract

BackgroundThe use of 3-dimensional highly porous acetabular cups is increasing. Their structure and mechanical properties mimic those of natural bone; therefore, they should promote stronger biological fixation. In our experience with total hip arthroplasty, radiolucent lines are observed when a 3-dimensional highly porous cup (Stryker Tritanium) is used. We compared the clinical and radiographic results between a Tritanium cup and a conventional cup (Stryker Trident HA) over a short time period. MethodWe retrospectively compared consecutive cases of primary total hip arthroplasty using a Tritanium cup (130 cases in 118 patients) and a matched cohort using a Trident cap (130 cases in 130 patients) between January 2011 and December 2014. ResultsThe mean follow-up duration was 41.3 and 38.1 months (p = 0.06) for the Tritanium and Trident groups, respectively. There were significant differences between the groups for radiolucent lines, cup abduction angle, and cup-center-edge angle. There were no significant differences in the clinical results. Radiolucent lines increased in the Tritanium group (36.1% at 3 months and 60.7% at final follow-up), whereas they decreased in the Trident group (2.5% at 3 months and 0.8% at final follow-up). The occurrence of radiolucent lines was significantly higher in the Tritanium group than in the Trident group at each follow-up period. Radiolucent lines were seen in 36.1% of patients in the Tritanium group during follow-up, without initial gaps. One cup loosening in the Tritanium group was identified at the final follow-up evaluation. ConclusionBoth groups showed successful clinical results over short-term follow-up; however, the Tritanium group had a significantly higher rate of radiolucent line occurrence around the cups than did the Trident group. Thus, radiolucent lines can occur when using highly porous titanium cups; these lines indicate the possibility of future cup loosening. Longer follow-up and assessment of the results of using this implant are necessary.