Comparison between PBE-D3, B3LYP, B3LYP-D3 and MP2 Methods for quantum mechanical calculations of polarizability and IR-NMR spectra in C24 isomers, including a novel isomer with D2d symmetry

Abstract

In this study, we have performed a comprehensive theoretical analysis of C24 isomers in the gaseous phase using the PBE-D3/cc-pVTZ, B3LYP/cc-pVTZ, B3LYP-D3/cc-pVTZ and MP2/6-31G methods. We have also considered the basis set cc-pVTZ for the MP2 method, and carried out optimized (single point) calculations in three isomers (in the remaining two isomers where the convergence was too time consuming) in order to reveal the potentiality of the method. Our investigation covered a wide range of properties, including geometry optimizations, chemical stability, polarizabilities, nuclear screening constants, Fermi (FE), gap (GE) and atomization energies (AE), thermodynamic analysis, reactivity index, as well as IR and NMR spectra. These calculations were performed for the ring (D12h), sheet (D6h) and two cage (D6d and Oh) configurations. Interestingly, we also proposed a new structure, the bracelet (D2d) arrangement, which appeared to be stable according to the PBE, B3LYP and B3LYP-D3 methods, but was classified as a transition state by the MP2 method. The results consistently indicated that the D6h isomer is the most stable one among the C24 isomers studied, while the D2d isomer was found to be the least stable. Regarding the gap energy (GE), the B3LYP and B3LYP-D3 methods consistently yielded higher values compared to the PBE’s, with an average DFT (PBE and B3LYP) GE of 1.89 eV, whereas the MP2 method showed a substantially higher GE value of 7.6 eV, representing an increase of approximately 75%. Additionally, the polarizabilities of the C24 isomers were found to be overestimated by the PBE, B3LYP and B3LYP-D3 methods when compared to the corresponding MP2 values. The PBE-D3 method consistently produced higher polarizabilities for the C24 isomers in comparison to the B3LYP, B3LYP-D3 and MP2 methods. The investigation confirms that the Oh (D12h) isomer has the smallest (largest) polarizability, as agreed upon by all methods. Moreover, the polarizability of D12h is notably affected by the selected DFT method, while that of Oh displays lower sensitivity but shares similarities with D6d. However, for the newly proposed D2d isomer, the polarizability is ranked third (fourth) in ascending order with the PBE-D3 (B3LYP-D3) method. This highlights the importance of considering the electronic correlation and dispersion effects in accurately predicting polarizabilities. The results obtained from the different methods shed light on the impact of the methodology choice on the predicted properties, emphasizing the need for careful consideration when analyzing and interpreting theoretical results for such various geometries.