Comparison Between Dual-Armature Linear Switched Flux Permanent Magnet Machine and Linear Surface-Mounted Permanent Magnet Machine Considering Thermal Conditions

Abstract

It has been proved that dual-armature permanent magnet (PM) machines have higher power density than conventional PM machines under the same copper loss. However, the thermal conditions of these machines are different. This paper makes a fair comparison between a dual-armature linear switched flux PM machine (DALSFPMM) and a linear surface-mounted PM machine (LSPMM) by considering both electromagnetic performances and thermal conditions. First, the topologies of two machines and platform are introduced. Then, the 2D and 3D finite element (FE) models are employed for the electromagnetic and thermal analyses, respectively. During the machine optimization, the thermal analysis is used to determine the copper loss under the fixed machine dimensions, while the electromagnetic analysis is used to optimize the machine dimensions under the fixed copper loss. After iterations, two machines are optimized and their performances are compared. Under the limitations of 80 °C maximum PM temperature and 120 °C maximum winding temperature, the DALSFPMM can exhibit 38% higher thrust force density for the continuous duty and up to 43% higher thrust force density for the short-time duty. Finally, a prototype machine of DALSFPMM is tested to validate the analyses.