Comparing Outcomes of Acute Versus Gradual Surgical Correction in Brachymetatarsia

Abstract

Brachymetatarsia consists of a shortened metatarsal resulting in a shorter toe. Pain with shoe wear and cosmetic concerns are the main reasons for surgical intervention. Surgical techniques to increase metatarsal length include acute lengthening with interpositional bone grafting or gradual lengthening with callus distraction. We performed a retrospective cohort study for 1 surgeon's patients at 1 institution over 10 years. Twenty-nine feet in 22 patients met inclusion criteria for acute correction; 16 feet in 11 patients were included for gradual correction. Mean ages were 26.3 ± 12.1 and 27 ± 10.8 in the acute and gradual groups, respectively (p = .79). Most patients were female: 95.4% of acute cases and 90.1% of gradual cases. Most involved lengthening the fourth metatarsal: 86.7% and 100% of acute and gradual groups, respectively (p = .54). Correction obtained amounted to 14.4 ± 2.97 mm (range, 10-22 mm) in acute cases and 14.8 ± 2.39 mm (range, 10-20 mm) in gradual cases (p = .81). The mean percent increase in metatarsal length was 21.1 ± 14% for acute and 22.6 ± 12.4% for gradual (p = .72). Mean consolidation was 8.9 ± 2.51 weeks for acute and 21.4 ± 10.8 weeks for gradual (p = <.001). Nonunions were most common in the gradual group (37.5%) with need for more revisional surgery (43.5%) compared with the acute group; both were statistically significant. We conclude that acute brachymetatarsia correction can obtain correction similar to the gradual technique with fewer postoperative complications and less osseous consolidation time.