Comparing fecundity in parthenogenetic versus sexual populations of the freshwater snail Campeloma limum: is there a two‐fold cost of sex?

Abstract

Abstract. The predominance of sexuality in eukaryotes remains an evolutionary paradox, given the “two‐fold cost of sex” also known as the “cost of males.” [Correction added after online publication 29 January 2009: in the preceding sentence, extraneous words were deleted.] As it requires two sexual parents to reproduce and only one parthenogenetic parent, parthenogens should have twice the reproductive rate compared with their sexual counterparts and their genes should spread twice as fast, if all else is equal. Yet, parthenogenesis is relatively rare and considered an evolutionary dead‐end, while sexuality is the dominant form of reproduction in multicellular eukaryotes. Many studies have explored short‐term benefits of sex that could outweigh its two‐fold cost, but few have compared fecundity between closely related sexuals and parthenogens to first verify that “all else is equal” reproductively. We compared six fecundity measures between sexual and parthenogenetic populations of the freshwater snail, Campeloma limum, during a brooding cycle (1 year) across two drainages. Drainages were analyzed separately because of a significant drainage effect. In the Savannah drainage, fecundity was not significantly different between sexuals and parthenogens, even though parthenogens had significantly more empty egg capsules per brood. In the Ogeechee drainage, parthenogens had significantly more egg capsules with multiple embryos and more hatched embryos than sexuals. Taken over 1 year, embryo size was not significantly different between parthenogens and sexuals in either drainage. Given these results and the close proximity of sexual and parthenogenetic populations, it is perplexing why parthenogenetic populations have not completely replaced sexual populations in C. limum.