Comparing children mental health across countries: challenges and results

Abstract

Abstract Background The School Children Mental Health Europe was a EU funded project designed to set up a kit of instruments enabling cross EU comparisons. Methods A literature review allows to select the SDQ (Strengths and Difficulties questionnaire) to be administered to the parents and teachers after a validation process in each country and the Dominic Interactive (DI), a sort of video game designed to evaluate DSM more commune diagnoses on children 6 to 11 years old. Results Data were collected on 7682 children randomly selected in a two stages selection: schools by country and children within the schools for whom 1) either parent- or teacher SDQ were completed: Overall, 12.8 % of children have any probable disorder with significant inter-country differences, 8.4 % probable conduct disorder, and 2.0 % probable hyperactivity/inattention. Adjusting for socio-demographic variables and parental psychological distress, country of residence did not predict the odds of having any disorder. 2) Overall, 22.0% of children were identified per their own evaluation as having at least one mental disorder, ranging from 16.4% in the Netherlands to 27.9% in Bulgaria. The prevalence of internalizing disorders was 18.4% across countries and ranged from 11.8% in the Netherlands to 24.3% in Turkey. The prevalence of externalizing disorders was lower with an average of 7.8%, ranging from 3.5% in Turkey to 10.5% in Bulgaria. Combining samples across European countries, 1 in 5 children reported internalizing problems and 1 in 12 children externalizing problems. Conclusions This lecture aims to present and discuss child mental health measure instruments from different informants perspectives, comparisons across countries and the challenges for interpreting the differences.