Comparative study of two quick-analysis models for frozen startup of high-temperature heat pipes

Abstract

The alkali-metal high-temperature Heat Pipe (HP) is the common component connecting the reactor core and energy conversion device in Heat Pipe cooled Reactor (HPR). Due to the particularity of the working medium, the frozen startup of HP makes a great influence on the startup process of HPR system. In this paper, two quick-analysis models, the Improved Thermal Resistance Network (ITRN) method and the Pseudo Wick Thermal Conductivity (PWTC) method have been investigated and compared. The simulations of a sodium HP in a typical experiment are carried out by two methods in COMSOL. For simulation speed, the convergence time of a single HP using the quick-analysis models is about tens to hundreds of seconds depending on the computing equipment. The convergence of PWTC is 26.7% faster than that of ITRN. For simulation accuracy, except for the inevitable error near the flat-front, the relative error of ITRN is less than 6.94% and the relative error of PWTC is less than 8.24%. The maximum effective error of ITRN method is 34.84 K, while that of PTWC method is 58.21 K at the initial stage of startup. The TTransition = 651 K in PWTC is lower than the Texp. = 710 K in the experiment and the TTr = 701 K in ITRN, which affects the accuracy at the initial stage of startup. The error will decrease gradually in the thawing front advancing stage. For simulation analysis, some inherent defects and targeted model improvements of the two models are proposed. Through the detailed comparative study in this work, researchers can easily apply the appropriate model according to the specific requirements and avoid the defects during the simulation process.