Comparative Study of Performance using Five Different Gamma-ray Spectrometers for Thyroid Monitoring under Nuclear Emergency Situations.

Abstract

A performance test was carried out using five different gamma-ray spectrometers applicable to thyroid monitoring. The energy resolution and efficiency for 7.6-cm × 7.6-cm NaI(Tl), 5.1-cm × 5.1-cm CeBr3, 3.8-cm × 3.8-cm SrI2(Eu), and 2.5-cm × 2.5-cm SrI2(Eu) gamma-ray scintillation spectrometers and a CdTe gamma-ray semiconductor spectrometer were evaluated using the Oak Ridge Institute for Nuclear Studies thyroid-neck phantom with a mock I source for prompt thyroid monitoring after a nuclear emergency. The respective energy resolutions of the full-energy peak for ~0.360 MeV of 3.8-cm × 3.8-cm SrI2(Eu) and 2.5-cm × 2.5-cm SrI2(Eu) scintillation spectrometers were 4.2% and 4.3%, and these values were very close to the value obtained by the CdTe semiconductor spectrometer. The efficiencies of four of the gamma-ray spectrometers were compared based on the efficiency of the 7.6-cm × 7.6-cm NaI(Tl) scintillation spectrometer at 0 cm from the phantom surface, and these values were ~70% for 5.1-cm × 5.1-cm CeBr3, ~30% for 3.8-cm × 3.8-cm SrI2(Eu), 10% for 2.5-cm × 2.5-cm SrI2(Eu) and 2% for 1-cm × 0.1-cm CdTe. Furthermore, the detection limits at various dose rates for the four gamma-ray scintillation spectrometers were evaluated using the method based on International Organization for Standardization publication ISO 11929:2010.