Comparative study of operative treatment of mid shaft fracture of humerus by locking plate versus intramedullary interlocking nail

Abstract

<b>Background:</b> Treatment of humeral shaft fractures with intramedullary nailing compared with dynamic compression plating leads to comparable results. No single treatment option is superior in all circumstances for a particular fracture and each case has to be individualized <b>. Objectives:</b> Comparative assessment of results of plating and Intramedullary Nailing in a rural set up so that proper management techniques can be provided for better functional outcome and minimum complications. <b>Materials and Methods:</b> This prospective study was conducted over a period of three years on sixty patients with closed acute humeral shaft fracture requiring operative interventions. <b>Results:</b> Forty percent of cases were in the age group 31-40 years with males outnumbering females. Motor vehicle accidents (63.3%) were most frequent cause. Right humerus was more frequently (66.6%) involved. Maximum patients (40%) were operated within 4-6 days after injury. Out of 30 patients of plate group complications were: Infection-6.6%; delayed union-13.3%; shoulder movement restriction-13.3%; elbow movement restriction-6.6%. Out of 30 patients of nail group complications were: Splintering of fracture end-6.6%; infection-6.6%; delayed union-26.6%; shoulder movement restriction-13.3%; elbow movement restriction-6.6%; shoulder pain-46.6%. Maximum number of fractures (73.3% in plating group and 60% in nailing group) clinically united in the interval of 11-13 weeks. Maximum number of patients had radiological union in period of 12-16 weeks (73.3% plate group and 66.6% nail group). There was no significant difference between the two groups. On functional assessment, excellent results were obtained in 22 patients (73.3%) in locking plate group and 18 patients (60%) in locking nail group. <b>Conclusion:</b> For patients requiring surgical treatment of mid shaft humeral fractures, locking plating and interlocking intramedullary nailing both provide statistically comparable results but a higher rate of excellent and good results and a tendency for earlier union was seen with locking plating group in the present series.