Comparative study of bone cements prepared with either HA or alpha-TCP and functionalized methacrylates.

Abstract

The properties of bone cements prepared with both hydroxyapatite (HA) and alpha-tricalcium phosphate (alpha-TCP) and methacrylates containing acidic or basic groups are the main interest of this article. The presence of methacrylic acid or diethyl amino ethyl methacrylate as comonomers in the bone cement and both ceramic types as filler were found not to affect the amount of residual monomer, which was generally less than 4.5 wt%. In contrast, setting times, maximum temperature, and glass transition temperature were found to be composition dependent. For samples with acidic comonomer, a faster setting time, a higher maximum temperature, and higher glass transition temperatures were observed compared to those with the basic comonomer. The presence of the fillers slightly increased the setting time but did not affect the other parameters. The mechanical properties of the filled bone cements depended mainly on composition and type of testing. Both HA or alpha-TCP filled systems fulfilled the minimum compressive strength required for bone cement application, although a significantly lower value was observed for the alkaline comonomer systems. The minimum bending strength was not satisfied by any of these formulations. The tensile and shear strength of these composites ranged from 20 to 37.9 and from 18 to 27 MPa, respectively. In all cases it was higher for bone cements containing methacrylic acid. The results of this study suggest that the properties of dry unfilled bone cements prepared with MAA are comparable to CMW 3 in mechanical terms but inferior in their setting properties.