Comparative Study Between Doubly Salient PM Machine With New Stator/Rotor-Pole Number Combination and Biased Flux PM Machine

Abstract

This article compares the doubly salient permanent magnet machine (DSPMM) having 18/13-pole number combination with 18/17-pole biased flux permanent magnet machine (BFPMM) to verify its improvement in torque characteristics. In such DSPMM, the stator/rotor-pole number combination is 18/13 rather than the conventional one (i.e., 18/12) to achieve balanced three phases, sinusoidal phase flux linkage and back electromotive force (back EMF), small cogging torque, and low torque ripple. On the other hand, an 18/17-pole BFPMM having the similar structure with the 18/13-pole DSPMM is analyzed, which has the best torque performance among such machines with the same stator pole number. To further improve average torque, the inner-type flux focusing (IFC) method is employed in both 18/13-pole DSPMM and 18/17-pole BFPMM. Then, both machines are optimized under the fixed copper loss and envelope size. The comparison shows that both machines have comparably small torque ripple while the 18/13-pole DSPMM with IFC (IFC-DSPMM) exhibits 35% higher torque density and 100% higher ratio of torque to PM volume. An 18/13-pole IFC-DSPMM is manufactured and tested to experimentally validate the predicted results.