Comparative psychophysical characteristics of cutaneous CO2 laser and contact heat stimulation

Abstract

Psychophysical visual analog scaling can be used to reveal critical determinants of the neural processing underlying non-painful and painful heat sensations produced by radiant and contact heat stimulation. This study determined the stimulus-response (S-R) functions of cutaneous non-painful and painful heat stimuli delivered by an infra-red CO2 laser or by a contact thermode in a series of experiments in healthy volunteers. In experiment 1 ( n = 12), with the rating scale anchored at pain threshold, the S-R curve for brief (60 ms) laser pulse stimulation with a beam diameter of 10 mm was a negatively accelerating function. Transformation of laser stimulus intensity (W) into temperatures ( C) did not change the form of the S-R curve. In experiment 2 ( n=9), using the same laser stimulus parameters as in experiment 1, but without an anchored rating scale, the form of the S-R relationship did not change. In experiment 3 ( n =9), increases of the laser pulse duration up to 5 s and the beam diameter up to 18 mm produced linear S-R curves. In contrast, in experiment 4 ( n =21), the S-R curve for cutaneous contact heat stimuli applied for 5 s with an 18 mm diameter probe was best described by a positively accelerating power function with an exponent greater than 2.0. These experiments have (1) characterized the S-R functions for different parameters of infra-red laser stimulation of the skin, and (2) have shown that the form of the S-R function for innocuous and noxious heat sensation is influenced strongly by the physical conditions of heat stimulus application, including mechanical contact with the skin.