Comparative Evaluation of Surface Quality, Tool Wear, and Specific Cutting Energy for Wiper and Conventional Carbide Inserts in Hard Turning of AISI 4340 Alloy Steel.

Adel T Abbas,Faycal Benyahia,Saqib Anwar,Hazem Ali,Ahmed Elkaseer,Hussien Hegab

doi:10.3390/ma13225233

Abstract

This paper presents an experimental study into the comparative response of wiper and round-nose conventional carbide inserts coated with TiCN + AL2O3 + TiN when turning an AISI 4340 steel alloy. The optimal process parameters, as identified by pre-experiments, were used for both types of inserts to determine the machined surface quality, tool wear, and specific cutting energy for different cutting lengths. The wiper inserts provided a substantial improvement in the attainable surface quality compared with the results obtained using conventional inserts under optimal cutting conditions for the entire range of the machined lengths. In addition, the conventional inserts showed a dramatic increase in roughness with an increased length of the cut, while the wiper inserts showed only a minor increase for the same length of cut. A scanning electron microscope was used to examine the wear for both types of inserts. Conventional inserts showed higher trends for both the average and maximum flank wear with cutting length compared to the wiper inserts, except for lengths of 200–400 mm, where conventional inserts showed less average flank wear. A higher accumulation of deposited chips was observed on the flank face of the wiper inserts than the conventional inserts. The experimental results demonstrated that edge chipping was the chief tool wear mechanism on the rake face for both types of insert, with more edge chipping observed in the case of the conventional inserts than the wiper inserts, with negligible evidence of crater wear in either case. The wiper inserts were shown to have a higher specific cutting energy than those detected with conventional inserts. This was attributed to (i) the irregular nose feature of the wiper inserts differing from the simpler round nose geometry of the conventional inserts and (ii) a higher tendency of chip accumulation on the wiper inserts.

Highlights

Ultra-high-strength steels (HSS), known as advanced high-strength steels [1], are part of a group of superalloys that are widely used in structural [2,3], military [4], and aerospace industry applications [5], as they show sustainable performance under severe working conditions [6].In particular, ultra-HSS alloys possess a unique combination of high strength [7], fatigue resistance [8], and ductility [9], which make them prime candidates for applications such as power transmission gears, high-strength bolts, shafts, and airframe parts [10]
The AISI 4340 steel alloy is part of the family of ultra-HSS alloys that are broadly used in military applications [11], which require high-precision machining with tight dimensional accuracy and high surface quality
The results showed that the surface roughnesslevel levelproduced producedbybythe the conventional inserts increased by 290%

Summary

Introduction

Ultra-high-strength steels (HSS), known as advanced high-strength steels [1], are part of a group of superalloys that are widely used in structural [2,3], military [4], and aerospace industry applications [5], as they show sustainable performance under severe working conditions [6].In particular, ultra-HSS alloys possess a unique combination of high strength [7], fatigue resistance [8], and ductility [9], which make them prime candidates for applications such as power transmission gears, high-strength bolts, shafts, and airframe parts [10]. The AISI 4340 steel alloy is part of the family of ultra-HSS alloys that are broadly used in military applications [11], which require high-precision machining with tight dimensional accuracy and high surface quality. The superior properties of these materials, such as their high strength, cause rapid tool wear [14] with poor surface quality and inaccurate dimensional tolerances of the machined parts [15,16]. Motivated by the need to find a more efficient process for the machinability of HSS alloys, researchers have investigated precision hard turning [19] with the goal of developing both a tool with the necessary properties and geometries and defining the optimal process parameters required to overcome the high hardness of HSS materials [20]

Methods

Results

Conclusion