Comparative evaluation of oxidative and antioxidative capacity during high-flux hemodialysis using two different membranes

Abstract

In patients with end-stage renal disease (ESRD) cardiovascular morbidity and mortality are increased. Apart from traditional and uremia-specific factors oxidative stress has been implicated as a main risk factor. This study investigated the influence of two different high-flux hemodialysis membranes on parameters of oxidative stress during a dialysis session. 14 stable ESRD patients were enrolled in the study and randomly assigned to high-flux hemodialysis using either a polyamide membrane (Polyflux 14; PA group) or a new polysulfone membrane (Diacap Polysulfone HI PS 15; PS group). All patients received 6 treatments with the same membrane. During the 5th treatment parameters of dialysis efficiency, biocompatibility (cell counts, complement C3a, thrombin-antithrombin complex) and oxidative stress (lipid peroxides, total antioxidative capacity) were measured. Parameters of dialysis efficiency and biocompatibility were similar in both treatment groups. At the beginning of the dialysis session both groups showed a low to moderate level of oxidative stress and a reduced total antioxidative capacity as compared to healthy controls. Both parameters deteriorated significantly during the extracorporeal procedure with a similar magnitude in both membrane groups. No correlation between oxidative or antioxidative capacity and parameters of biocompatibility or dialysis efficiency could be found. Dialysis with synthetic high-flux membranes induces a temporary deterioration of oxidative stress parameters in ESRD patients despite good dialysis efficiency and biocompatibility.