Comparative Analysis of Lithium-Ion and Lead–Acid as Electrical Energy Storage Systems in a Grid-Tied Microgrid Application

Abstract

Microgrids (MGs) are a valuable substitute for traditional generators. They can supply inexhaustible, sustainable, constant, and efficient energy with minimized losses and curtail network congestion. Nevertheless, the optimum contribution of renewable energy resource (RER)-based generators in an MG is prohibited by its variable attribute. It cannot be effectively deployed due to its application’s power quality and stability issues. Therefore, an energy storage system is employed to alleviate the variability of RERs by stabilizing the power demand against irregular generation. Electrical energy storage systems (EESSs) are regarded as one of the most beneficial methods for storing dependable energy supply while integrating RERs into the utility grid. Conventionally, lead–acid (LA) batteries are the most frequently utilized electrochemical storage system for grid-stationed implementations thus far. However, due to their low life cycle and low efficiency, another contending technology known as lithium-ion (Li-ion) is utilized. This research presents a feasibility study approach using ETAP software 20.6 to analyze the performance of LA and Li-ion batteries under permissible charging constraints. The design of an optimal model is a grid-connected microgrid system consisting of a PV energy source and dynamic load encompassed by Li-ion and LA batteries. Finally, the comparative study led to significant conclusions regarding the specific attributes of both battery technologies analyzed through the operation, revealing that Li-ion is a more conducive energy storage system than LA.