Comparative Analysis of Flux Reversal Permanent Magnet Machines With Toroidal and Concentrated Windings

Abstract

In this article, the flux reversal permanent magnet (FRPM) machine with toroidal windings is presented and analyzed with reference to conventional concentrated windings. First, the influence of rotor pole numbers on FRPM machines with conventional concentrated windings is investigated. It is found that although the 12/13 stator slot/rotor pole FRPM machine has a high back electromotive force, the pitch factor, and magnet flux utilization ratio of concentrated windings are very low. By adopting toroidal windings instead of concentrated windings in the 12/13 FRPM machine, the pitch factor and resulted machine performance can be effectively improved. Finite-element analysis shows that the 12/13 FRPM machine with toroidal windings can produce 79% higher torque than its counterpart with concentrated windings. Then, the critical design parameters and detailed electromagnetic performance of FRPM machines with both winding types are analyzed and compared. It is shown that the machine with toroidal windings has higher torque, efficiency, power factor, and lower torque ripple, making it particularly suitable for low-speed, high-torque, and axial length limited applications. In addition, other feasible stator slot/rotor pole combinations to use toroidal winding are identified, with the aid of equivalent pole-pair number. Finally, two 12/13 FRPM prototypes with toroidal windings and concentrated windings are tested to validate the analyses.