Comparaison des taux d’échec et des résultats fonctionnels entre les autogreffes d’ischio-jambiers et les greffes hybrides pour la reconstruction du ligament croisé antérieur : revue systématique avec méta-analyse

Abstract

BackgroundThe viability of augmenting small-diameter hamstring autografts with allografts remains unclear. Recent studies have reported different clinical results after allograft augmentation. Hence, we sought to determine whether hamstring autografts and hybrid grafts differed in terms of failure rates and functional outcomes after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction. We also evaluated whether the results of the comparisons differed based on allograft sterilization methods. Patients and methodsThis systematic review and meta-analysis were performed by searching the PubMed, Cochrane Library, and EMBASE databases to identify prospective or retrospective studies (evidence levels 1, 2, or 3) that compared the failure rates and functional outcomes of ACL reconstruction using autografts and hybrid grafts. ResultsWe identified 15 relevant studies, including 1521 patients, with 798 and 723 treated using autografts and hybrid grafts, respectively. Fourteen studies were retrospective comparative studies, and one was a prospective randomized controlled trial. Of these, three studies used non-irradiated allografts. In the analysis of all participants, no significant differences in failure rates and subjective International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) scores were observed between the autograft and hybrid graft groups. Comparing the autograft and hybrid graft groups that used non-irradiated allografts, no differences in the failure rates and subjective IKDC scores were also noted. Meanwhile, in the groups that used irradiated allograft, the autograft group demonstrated higher Lysholm knee scores and reduced anterior laxity than the hybrid graft group. DiscussionOverall, ACL reconstruction using hybrid grafts may not reduce failure rates compared to reconstructions using hamstring autografts, although hybrid grafts with irradiation may decrease functional outcomes. Level of evidenceIII; systematic review of level II and III studies.