Comparaison de l'efficacité analgésique de la nalbuphine et de son association au propacétamol en phase postopératoire immédiate de chirurgie gynéco-obstétricale

Abstract

This prospective randomized single-blind study compared the efficacy of a combination of propacetamol (2 g) and a low dose of nalbuphine hydrochloride (10 mg) with nalbuphine hydrochloride (20 mg) alone, in a population of 152 white female patients after gynaecologic or obstetrical surgery, for alleviation of postoperative pain in recovery room. The drugs were administered intravenously in case of pain. The population was divided into two groups : group 1 received 20 mg of nalbuphine hydrochloride and group 2 received 2 g of propacetamol combined with 10 mg of nalbuphine hydrochloride. The pain intensity was studied with the visual analogue scale and comparisons use no parametric tests (Mann and Whitney test, Kruskall and Wallis test) and Chi 2 test. Groups were similar for age, surgical and anaesthesia procedures and initial pain level. The propacetamol-nalbuphine hydrochloride 10 mg association provided a significantly better analgesia than nalbuphine 20 mg during the first two postoperative hours (p < 0.05). In group 1, the analgesia score decrease was respectively 28 ± 25 mm (range : 33–75 mm) after 1 h and 31 ± 25 mm (range : 26–84 mm) after 2 h. In group 2, the decrease was more important : 37 ± 21 mm (range : 5–84 mm) after 1 h and 42 ± 23 mm (range : 20–84 mm) after 2 h. Side effects were minimal and similar in both groups (nausea, drowsiness). It is concluded that a propacetamol-nalbuphine hydrochloride 10 mg association provides better analgesia than single dose of 20 mg of nalbuphine. This association convenient analgesia with a decreased dose of nalbuphine.