Community Science Strategies Reveal Distributional Patterns of Treponeme-Associated Hoof Disease in Washington Elk (Cervus canadensis)

Abstract

Treponeme-associated hoof disease (TAHD) is an emerging disease of conservation concern in elk (Cervus canadensis) in the Northwest USA. Elk with TAHD exhibit characteristic hoof lesions that are often accompanied by lameness and limping. The gold standard approach traditionally used for infectious disease surveillance is laboratory confirmation, which for TAHD is a histologic examination of abnormal elk hooves submitted by wildlife agencies. Diagnostic evaluation affords certainty in confirming TAHD; however, these examinations are also labor and resource intensive, and therefore, not conducive to the collection of sufficient data for epidemiologic investigations. In response, two community science (CS) surveillance strategies have been implemented in Washington State: public observations of limping elk from a web-based reporting tool and hunter reports of hoof abnormalities on harvested elk. Surveillance using CS strategies can be implemented widely and may be useful for describing broad distributional patterns of TAHD, despite their unknown relationship to laboratory-confirmed cases. We described and compared the spatial–temporal distribution of TAHD in western Washington game management units (GMU) using the two CS strategies to assess congruences and discrepancies between observed patterns. We used spatial scan statistics to identify possible core-affected and newly emerging areas at the GMU level. Lastly, we contrasted CS observations against confirmed case data to examine possible delays in TAHD detection and co-occurrence among surveillance strategies. We found public observations of limping elk often predated TAHD confirmations in GMUs by several years, while hunter-reported abnormalities predated confirmations in GMUs by several months. High co-occurrence between the presence of apparent and confirmed cases under different surveillance strategies further supports the use of CS sources. This study capitalizes on wide-reaching CS data to provide new and complementary epidemiological information that can help guide future surveillance, management, and research efforts for this novel elk hoof disease.