Community composition of butterflies and bumblebees in fallows: niche breadth and dispersal capacity modify responses to fallow type and landscape

Abstract

Fallows (i.e. fields temporarily taken out of production) provide important habitat for flower-visiting insects in intensively cultivated agricultural landscapes. Cost-efficiency of fallowing schemes could be enhanced through improved understanding of key characteristics of fallows and surrounding landscape that determine community composition and provide support for species of conservation concern. Impacts of fallow characteristics and landscape structure on the species composition of butterflies and bumblebees were studied in two types of perennial fallows in boreal farmland. To understand species’ responses to environmental factors from a conservation perspective, community composition was examined with respect to two species traits—niche breadth and dispersal capacity. Whereas overall species composition of butterflies and bumblebees was strongly affected by forest cover in the surrounding landscape, the studied species traits were most related to fallow type and the cover of perennial grasslands. Habitat breadth of butterflies was narrowest in long-term grassland fallows in landscapes with high grassland cover. Dispersal capacity of butterflies was also lowest in grassland-rich landscapes. Diet breadth of bumblebees was narrower in long-term grassland fallows than in short-term fallows. The results confirm that the diversity of butterflies and bumblebees can be enhanced by establishing and managing fallows both in open and forested landscapes. For conservation of habitat specialists and less mobile species, retention of long-term fallows in grassland-rich landscapes is apparently the best option. The results provide no justification for exempting forested regions or farms with high grassland cover from the ecological focus area requirement under the European Union’s current agricultural policy.