Comment on nhess-2023-40

Abstract

<strong class="journal-contentHeaderColor">Abstract.</strong> Additive Logistic Regression models for lightning and large hail (<em>AR_hail</em>) were developed using convective parameters from the ERA5 reanalysis, hail reports from the European Severe Weather Database (ESWD), and lightning observations from the Met Office Arrival Time Difference network (ATDnet). The model yields the probability of large hail in a given timeframe over a particular grid point and can accurately reproduce the climatological distribution and the seasonal cycle of observed hail events in Europe. To explore the value of this approach to medium-range forecasting, a similar four-dimensional model was developed using predictor parameters retrieved from ECMWF reforecasts: Most Unstable CAPE, 925&ndash;500 hPa bulk shear, Mixed Layer Mixing Ratio, and the Wet Bulb Zero Height. This model was applied to the ECMWF reforecasts to compute probabilistic large hail forecasts for all available 11 ensemble members, from 2008 to 2019 and for lead times up to 228 hours. First, we compared the hail ensemble forecasts for different lead times with observed hail occurrence from the ESWD focusing on a recent hail outbreak. Secondly, we evaluated the model&rsquo;s predictive skill as a function of forecast lead time using the Area under the ROC Curve (AUC) as a validation score. This analysis showed that <em>AR_hail</em> has a very high predictive skill (AUC &gt; 0.95) for a lead time up to 60 hours. <em>AR_hail</em> retains a high predictive skill even for extended forecasts (AUC = 0.86 at 180 hours lead time). Finally, the performance of the four-dimensional model was compared with that of composite parameters such as the Significant Hail Parameter (SHP) or the product of CAPE and the 925&ndash;500 hPa bulk shear (CAPESHEAR). Results show that <em>AR_hail</em> outperformed CAPESHEAR at all lead times and SHP at short to medium lead times. This suggests that the combination of Additive Logistic Regression models and ECMWF ensemble forecasts can create highly skilful medium-range hail forecasts for Europe.