Comment on gmd-2023-10

Abstract

<strong class="journal-contentHeaderColor">Abstract.</strong> The paper investigates how to refine the ground meteorological observation network for greatly improving the PM_2.5 concentration forecasts by identifying the sensitive areas for targeted observations associated with a total of 48 forecasts in eight heavy haze events during the years of 2016&ndash;2018 over the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei (BTH) region. The conditional non-linear optimal perturbation (CNOP) method is adopted to determine the sensitive area of the surface meteorological fields for each forecast and a total of 48 CNOP-type errors are obtained including wind, temperature, and water vapor mixing ratio components. It is found that, although all the sensitive areas tend to locate within and/or surrounding the BTH region, their specific distributions are dependent on the events and the start times of the forecasts. Based on these sensitive areas, the current ground meteorological stations within and surrounding the BTH region are refined to form a cost-effective observation network, which makes the relevant PM_2.5 forecasts starting from different initial times for varying events assimilate fewer observations but overall achieve the forecasting skill comparable to, even higher than that obtained by assimilating all ground station observations. This network sheds light on that some of the current ground stations within and surrounding the BTH region are very useless for improving the PM_2.5 forecasts in the BTH region and can be greatly scattered to avoid the thankless work.