Comment on egusphere-2023-666

Abstract

<strong class="journal-contentHeaderColor">Abstract.</strong> Several studies have demonstrated the ability of Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) machine learning based modeling to outperform traditional spatially lumped process-based modeling approaches for streamflow prediction. However, due mainly to the structural complexity of the LSTM network (which includes gating operations and sequential processing of the data), difficulties can arise when interpreting the internal processes and weights in the model. Here, we propose and test a modification of LSTM architecture that represents internal system processes in a manner that is analogous to a hydrological reservoir. Our architecture, called HydroLSTM, simulates behaviors inherent in a dynamic system, such as sequential updating of the Markovian storage. Specifically, we modify how data is fed to the new representation to facilitate simultaneous access to past lagged inputs, thereby explicitly acknowledging the importance of trends and patterns in the data. We compare the performance of the HydroLSTM and LSTM architectures using data from 10 hydro-climatically varied catchments. We further examine how the new architecture exploits the information in lagged inputs, for 588 catchments across the USA. The HydroLSTM-based models require fewer cell states to obtain similar performance to their LSTM-based counterparts. Further, the weights patterns associated with lagged input variables are interpretable and consistent with regional hydroclimatic characteristics (snowmelt-dominated, recent rainfall-dominated, and historical rainfall-dominated). These findings illustrate how the hydrological interpretability of LSTM-based models can be enhanced by appropriate architectural modifications that are physically and conceptually consistent with our understanding of the system.