Comment on egusphere-2023-464

Abstract

<strong class="journal-contentHeaderColor">Abstract.</strong> In moderate to heavy precipitation, rain droplets may deteriorate Doppler lidars' accuracy for measuring the line-of-sight wind velocity because their projected velocity on the beam direction differs greatly from that of air. Therefore, we propose a method of effectively filtering away the adverse effects of rain on velocity estimation by sampling the Doppler spectra faster than the rain drops' beam transit time. By using a special averaging procedure, we can suppress the rain signal by sampling the spectrum at 3 kHz. On a moderately rainy day with a maximum rain intensity of 4 mm/h, three ground-based continuous-wave Doppler lidars were used to conduct a field measurement campaign at the Ris&oslash; campus of the Technical University of Denmark. We demonstrate that the rain bias can effectively be removed by normalizing the noise-flattened Doppler spectra with their peak values before they are averaged down to 50 Hz prior to the determination of the speed. In comparison to the sonic anemometer measurements acquired at the same location, the wind velocity bias at 50 Hz is reduced from up to &minus;1.58 m/s of the conventional lidar data to &minus;0.18 m/s of the normalized lidar data. This significant reduction of the bias occurs at the minute with the highest amount of rain when the measurement distance of the lidar is 103.9 m with a corresponding probe length being 9.8 m. With the smallest probe length, 1.2 m, the rain-induced bias was only present at the period with the highest rain intensity and was also effectively eliminated with the procedure. Thus the proposed method for reducing the impact of rain on continuous-wave Doppler lidar measurements of air velocity is promising, without requiring much computational effort.