Comment on “Coherent states for the hydrogen atom”

Abstract

Majumdar and Sharatchandra recently proposed a set of ``coherent states'' for the hydrogen atom [Phys. Rev. A 56, R3322 (1997)]. These states satisfy some of the typical properties of coherent states, such as, for example, continuity in the parameters. The time evolution of these states is given by the classical evolution of the angle variables, and the expectation values of the quantum observables behave quasiclassically. However, those authors also claimed that, although one does not obtain exactly the same state after a Kepler period, the gross features of their wave packets do not change. We show that this is not correct, and that these wave packets do not remain localized on the classical variables, but spread rapidly over the Keplerian orbit. The localization properties of these states do not improve in the limit of large quantum numbers.