Comment on bg-2022-203

Abstract

Across tropical ecosystems, global environmental change is causing drier climatic conditions and increases in nutrient depositions. Such changes represent large uncertainties due to unknown interactions between drought and nutrient availability in controlling ecosystem net primary productivity (NPP). Using a large-scale manipulative experiment, we studied whether nutrient availability affects the responses of three component NPP fluxes (stem growth, fine roots production, and litterfall) to through-fall exclusion in 30-year-old unmanaged mixed plantations of six tree species native to the tropical dry forest of Costa Rica. We used a factorial design with four treatments: control (CN), fertilization (F), drought (D), and drought+fertilization (D+F). While we found that a 13–15 % reduction in soil moisture only led to modest effects in the studied ecosystem processes, NPP increased as a function of F and D+F. At the same time, NPP increases with nutrient additions were larger in the plots without throughfall exclusion. The relative contribution of each biomass flux to NPP varied depending on the treatment, with woody biomass being more important for F and root biomass for D+F and D. Moreover, seasonal canopy cover was maintained longer in the fertilized plots. Belowground processes such as nodulation and microbial carbon use efficiency (CUE) also responded to experimental treatments, with a decrease in nodulation for F plots and an increase in CUE for F and D plots. Species functional type (i.e., N-fixation or deciduousness) and not the experimental manipulations were the main source of variation in tree relative growth rates. Our results emphasize that nutrient availability moderately constrains ecosystem processes in tropical dry forests, but this depends on water availability.