Comment on bg-2021-278

Abstract

The partitioning of water fluxes in the critical zone is of great interest due to the implications for understanding water cycling and quantifying water availability for various ecosystem services. We used the tracer-aided ecohydrological model EcH2O-iso to evaluate water, energy, water stable isotope, and biomass dynamics at an intensively monitored study plot under two willow trees, a riparian species, in Berlin, Germany. Importantly, we assessed the value of in-situ soil and plant water isotope data to quantify xylem water sources and transit times, with coupled estimates of the temporal dynamics and ages of soil and root-uptake water. The willows showed high evapotranspiration water use, with limited percolation of summer precipitation to deeper soil layers due to the dominance of shallow root-uptake (> 80 % in the upper 10 cm). Lower evapotranspiration under grass resulted in higher soil moisture storage, greater soil evaporation and more percolation of soil water. Biomass allocation was predominantly foliage growth (57 % in grass and 78 % in willow). Shallow soil water age under grass was similar to under willows (15–17 days). Considering potential xylem transit times showed a large improvement in the model's capability to estimate xylem isotopic composition and water age, and revealed the high value of in-situ data within modelling. Root-uptake was predominately derived from summer precipitation events (56 %) and had an average age of 35 days, with xylem transport times taking at least 6.2–8.1 days. By evaluating water partitioning, energy and isotope mass-balance, along with biomass allocation, the model revealed multifaceted capabilities for assessing water cycling within the critical zone at high temporal resolution, including xylem water sources and transport, which are all necessary for short and long-term assessment of water availability for plant growth.