Comment on bg-2021-159

Abstract

Mangroves are widely recognised as key ecosystems for climate change mitigation as they capture and store significant amounts of sediment organic carbon (SOC). Yet, there is incomplete knowledge on how sources of SOC and their differential preservation vary between mangrove sites in relation to environmental gradients. To address this, sediment depth profiles were sampled from mangrove sites ranging from river-dominated to marine-dominated sites and including old and young mangrove sites, in the Guayas delta (Ecuador). The stable carbon isotope ratios (δ13C) and the elemental composition (OC%, C : N) of sediment profiles, local vegetation (i.e., autochthonous carbon) and externally-supplied suspended particulate matter (i.e., allochthonous carbon) were obtained to assess variations in the amount and sources of SOC at different locations throughout the delta. In general, across all sites, we found increasing SOC contents and stocks are associated with decreasing δ13C and increasing C / N ratios, indicating that SOC stocks and sources are intrinsically related. The SOC stocks (down to 0.64 m deep profiles) are significantly lower in young mangrove sites (46–55 Mg C ha−1) than in old sites (78–92 Mg C ha−1). The SOC in the young mangrove sites is mainly of allochthonous origin (estimated on average at 79 %) whereas in the old sites there is a slight dominance of autochthonous OC (on average 59 %). Moreover, from river- to marine-dominated sites, a pattern was found of increasing SOC stocks and increasing autochthonous SOC contribution. These observed differences along the two studied gradients are hypothesized to be mainly driven by (1) expected higher sedimentation rates in the river-dominated and lower-elevation younger sites, thereby “diluting” the SOC content and decreasing the relative autochthonous contribution; and (2) potential differences in preservation of the different SOC sources. Our finding of high contributions of allochthonous SOC, especially in young mangroves, implies that this carbon is not originating from CO2 sequestration by the mangrove ecosystem itself, but is externally supplied from other terrestrial, marine or estuarine ecosystems. We argue that accounting for lower SOC stocks and higher contribution of allochthonous SOC in young and river-dominated mangrove sites, as compared to old and marine-dominant sites, is particularly relevant for designing and valuing nature-based climate mitigation programs based on mangrove reforestation.