Combining stable isotope ratios with elemental concentrations to improve the estimation of terrestrial carnivore diets

Abstract

Stable isotopes of animal tissue have been used to estimate diet for many consumer species and places, but the ability to assign contributions to all food items is limited by the number of tracers used, and the separation of the tracer data among the dietary sources. We tested whether we could detect caribou (Rangifer tarandus) in the diet of individual predators in southwest Canada, where caribou are endangered. The separation between caribou tissue and that of other common prey was minimal using C13 and N15 isotope ratios and our confidence in assigning the caribou diet fraction correctly was low despite testing several fractionation values and priors. We measured the concentration of a suite of elements in the tissue of lichen, large prey and predators to investigate whether we could use an elemental concentration as a diet tracer and better assign the caribou diet fraction, because several of these elements were known to be more abundant in lichen, a major food for caribou in winter. Strontium and cesium had higher concentrations, when normalized by a common salt (we chose calcium), in caribou tissue than the other prey species we measured; this was also true for strontium isotope ratios. The elemental tracers appeared to overestimate caribou in the diet however, we suggest that the addition of either cation could yield finer and more accurate estimates of diet for large terrestrial predators after further investigation. The addition of a strontium isotope ratio tracer to a diet investigation may be equally informative and require less pre-work, because one ratio (Sr87/Sr86) has already been well studied.