Combining perennial ryegrass cultivars in seed mixtures confers limited and situation-specific benefits for dairy pasture productivity

Abstract

ABSTRACT Combining several cultivars within species in seed mixtures is often advocated as a means for improving crop or pasture performance. Herbage accumulation (HA) of perennial ryegrass-white clover pastures sown with a single cultivar representing different functional types of perennial ryegrass was compared with the HA of cultivar mixtures over three years in two contrasting environments (Waikato, dryland; Canterbury, irrigated) under dairy cattle grazing. Functional types were: mid-season flowering diploid, late-season diploid, and late-season tetraploid. Mixture treatments (n = 4 at each site) included all binary combinations plus the three-way combination. Mixture HA and the mean HA of the constituent cultivars did not differ for any of the mixture combinations in either environment, apart from winter in Waikato where the mid-diploid plus tetraploid mix out-yielded the mean of the individual cultivars and tended to increase total annual HA. The total annual HA of the mixtures was between 1.0 and 2.3 t DM/ha/year less than the HA of the highest-yielding individual cultivar included in the mixture in six of the eight mixture-environment combinations. While some benefits of mixtures for controlling grazing outcomes were observed, sowing individual high-performing cultivars is a better overall strategy than mixing cultivars to cover a spectrum of traits.