Colonic Motility in Profoundly Disabled People: A comparison of massage and laxative therapy in the management of constipation

Abstract

Summary This pilot study compared abdominal massage with laxative treatment in the management of constipation in 32 profoundly disabled, institutionalised adults. A randomised cross-over design was used. After an initial 16-day baseline measurement phase without any treatment, there followed two seven-week treatment phases separated by a one-week washout period. Each subject received seven weeks of massage and seven weeks on his or her previous laxative regimen. Primary outcome measures were gastro-intestinal and segmental transit times, measured at the end of the baseline phase and of each treatment phase. Secondary measures included stool frequency, size and consistency, the requirement for enemas and an assessment of patient well-being. The median value of total colonic transit time was 183 hours for the baseline phase and 159 hours for all treatment phases. There was no evidence of any statistically significant treatment differences between laxative and massage therapy for right, left or rectosigmoid segments either separately or in total. Analysis of secondary outcome measures also failed to find any treatment preferences. These results reveal the grossly abnormal colonic transit times of the study population at all times. The effects of laxative and massage therapy within this environment were not demonstrably different.