Colonial Waterbird Predation and Angler Catch of Hatchery Rainbow Trout Stocked in Southern Idaho Fisheries

Abstract

AbstractThe abundance of piscivorous colonial waterbirds such as double‐crested cormorants Phalacrocorax auritus and American white pelicans Pelecanus erythrorhynchos has increased dramatically in recent decades in North America, resulting in increased conflict between these birds and fisheries resources, which raises the need to quantify the effects of waterbird predation on fisheries. We estimated avian predation and angler use of two sizes of hatchery‐reared Rainbow Trout Oncorhynchus mykiss (250 mm and 300 mm on average; termed standard catchables and magnum catchables) at 15 Idaho waters with known cormorant and pelican presence. Fish were tagged with passive integrated transponder (PIT), radio, and T‐bar anchor tags prior to release; the tags were subsequently recovered from bird nesting, roosting, and loafing sites. Estimated angler use, which included fish harvested as well as those that were catch‐and‐release, averaged 17%, while avian predation averaged 35%. Angler catch at study waters declined exponentially as avian predation increased. Predation specifically attributed to double‐crested cormorants and American white pelicans was related to their relative abundance at the waterbodies where the fish were stocked. Avian predation rates were similar for standard and magnum catchables, suggesting that larger fish were not able to escape predation any better than smaller ones. Our results add to existing evidence indicating that in some southern Idaho fisheries, piscivorous birds, rather than anglers, are the dominant consumers of hatchery trout. This study further contributes to the larger issue of competition between humans, wildlife, and fisheries populations.