Colloid Cyst: Revision of Third Ventricular Zones for Risk Stratification of Hydrocephalus

Abstract

We sought to reclassify the "anatomic risk zones of colloid cysts" as proposed by Beaumont etal, by proposing newer landmarks, and to assess predictive value for the risk of occurrence of hydrocephalus with the new classification compared with the old. A retrospective cohort of 122 cases of colloid cyst of third ventricle were categorized into zones 1, 2, or 3 based on Beaumont's classification (old zone) and our classification (new zone) based on radiologic images. We attempted to recategorize these zones by assigning new anatomic landmarks. The difference in zonal distribution of colloid cyst and association with hydrocephalus was studied using the 2 methods of zonal classification. Per the old zone classification, 3/122 patients were in zone 2, whereas 21/122 were in zone 2 per the new zone classification. The new zone method had a higher specificity (36.21% vs. 5.263 %) and positive predictive value (63.37% vs. 54.23%) for occurrence of hydrocephalus in patients with colloid cyst. The Spearman correlation showed better correlation with the new method for occurrence of hydrocephalus (rho= 0.4 [P < 0.00000] vs. 0.2 [P= 0.011]). Symptomatic colloid cysts are more likely to develop hydrocephalus and sudden acute deterioration. The colloid cyst risk score is a step towards objective decision making, with scope for modification such as the one that we have attempted with new zone classification to achieve superior prognostic ability.