Cognitive Coping vs Emotional Disclosure in the Treatment of Anxious Children: A Pilot-Study

Abstract

The present pilot-study was a first attempt to examine the effectiveness of the cognitive component of cognitive behaviour therapy for children with anxiety problems. A total of 24 highly anxious children were assigned to 1 of 2 intervention conditions: a Cognitive Coping intervention, which focussed primarily on the cognitive component of cognitive behaviour therapy, or an Emotional Disclosure intervention in which children were invited to write about their fears and anxious experiences. Children completed self-report questionnaires of anxiety disorders symptoms and worry at 3 points in time: (i) 6 weeks before treatment (i.e. baseline), (ii) at pre-treatment, and (iii) at post-treatment. The results showed, firstly, that levels of anxiety disorder symptoms and worry remained relatively stable over a 6-week waiting period and then decreased substantially after the interventions. This suggests that the children did not suffer from momentary anxiety and worry complaints and that treatments generally were effective in reducing these symptoms. Secondly, although within-group comparisons suggested that treatment effects were somewhat larger in the Cognitive Coping condition than in the Emotional Disclosure condition (effects sizes for anxiety disorders symptoms and worry were, respectively, 1.03 and 0.87 for Cognitive Coping vs 0.54 and 0.39 for Emotional Disclosure), statistical tests could not substantiate this impression, probably due to a lack of power as a result of the small numbers of children in both intervention conditions.